Thursday, June 28, 2007

SMEs Research

SMEs play an important role in the UK’s economy, but have largely been left behind in terms of developments in the postal market over the past 5 years. The change in the pricing structure to Pricing in Proportion (PiP) had a significant, mainly detrimental, effect on SMEs and the opening of the market has not afforded them the choice available to larger businesses due to the minimum volume requirements of licensed operators. There has been a large drop in the minimum volumes required; from mailings in their thousands at the beginning of 2006, down to mailings of just 250 today, allowing more SMEs the option of switching.

Postwatch has played an active role in the promotion and protection of SMEs interests and our Mailers Consultative Group has allowed excellent working relationships with various representative bodies (Federation of Small Businesses, British Chambers of Commerce, The Forum of Private Business and a number of charities).

Postwatch is currently undertaking research on SMEs and what their current and future needs are. There is a belief amongst many SMEs that they are not in a position to switch and an accompanying argument that if they don’t know that a product or service is unavailable, they will be unable to make comment on it. The aim of this research is to overcome these barriers.

The objective of this research is to gain a real understanding of the way both small and medium sized enterprises currently use the postal service and how they see this changing in the future. It is important that we are in a position to offer them a range of alternatives regarding the future of postal services to comment on and these will need to be comprehensively researched before a questionnaire is designed.

This project was recently commissioned and the results of the research are expected at the end of the year, with the research being published early next year.

USO Research

Following considerable change in the postal industry in recent years, there is increasing debate surrounding the Universal Service Obligation and whether its current form is both sustainable and fulfilling the needs of citizens. As the consumer watchdog for the postal industry, Postwatch is keen to understand the issues surrounding the USO debate from a citizen’s perspective, in order to contribute to the debate and represent citizens’ viewpoints correctly. Evidence of citizens’ needs and wants, and an analysis of the current and possible future USO structures will allow Postwatch to understand the issues fully, and represent citizens accordingly.

The primary objective of the research is to assess whether the current USO is fulfilling the needs of citizens, with ‘citizens’ being all postal users and potential users, and both senders and receivers. Further objectives that will feed into and from this primary objective are: to assess what citizens’ needs are from a USO; to assess the effects on the existing USO from present and future competition; to assess alternative models of USO provision; and to undertake a valuation of the USO from the perspective of citizens.

The project was recently commissioned, with results expected to be received by Postwatch at the end of the year and published in early 2008.

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

The challenge to Postwatch

Nationwide Post Office Limited is currently in the process of franchising some 70 Crown offices into WHSmith outlets and, over the next 18 months, some 2,500 offices will actually close (although around 500 will be replaced by outreach arrangements).

A taste of the challenge faced by Postwatch as these exercises roll out came from a public meeting this week in Fulham in London when the local (Conservative) Council organised a protest meeting against the intended franchising of the Farm Lane Crown office to the WHSmith outlet in nearby North End Road. The meeting was addressed by Postwatch's Greater London Chairman Roger Darlington who predictably received a tough reception since Postwatch cannot veto such a proposal and can understand the case for franchising. You can read an account of the meeting from a local (Conservative) councillor here.

Some of the many issues which came up in Fulham - which will certainly come up elsewhere - were as follows:
  • Customers find it hard to understand how a Crown office can be loss-making when it is seemingly so busy. More explanation is necessary about the falling number of transactions and the low margin on most transactions and, if POL does feel able to give more local financial data, that would be very helpful.
  • Customers cannot understand how, if POL cannot make money from a particular office, then a franchisee like WHSmith apparently can. Again more explanation is necessary, this time about the different business model which franchisees operate, including shared property costs, lower staff costs and greater footfall.
  • Residents find it hard to envisage how the facilities of a Crown office can be fitted inside an already full retail outlet like a WHSmith shop. It would be really helpful if they could be shown actual layouts and plans with full details of the number of counters and floor space.
  • Most controversially people don't understand why the consumer watchdog does not simply oppose any franchising or closure proposal when it is clear that all those at the protest meeting do not want it. It is tough but we have to explain that such hard decisions are likely to make the overall network more sustainable and the alternative is continued, unplanned closures such as we have seen for decades.
  • Finally there are constant demands that the post office network should not be required to behave commercially and should be subsidized by government with much party political posturing against the present government. Postwatch is of course politically neutral and can only operate within the context set by the government of the day. But we need to point out that there is in fact a measure of subsidy to the post office network (the social network payment of £150M a year) and the forthcoming closure programme has been reluctantly accepted as necessary by the cross-party Select Committee on Trade & Industry.

Labels: ,

The Future of UK Postal Services

Last Monday the Institute of Economic Affairs held their 6th annual conference on The Future of UK Postal Services in London. Although the media have honed in on the fact that Sarah Chambers, Chief Executive of Postcomm, stated that the number of deliveries received each week, currently six, could be an area for future discussion, there were also a number of other interesting points that were raised.

It's clear that a debate on the Universal Service Obligation (USO) is desired by Royal Mail, their competitors and Postcomm. This is likely to include which products are included in the future, with Royal Mail envisaging only stamped mail enjoying USO protection. There are also debates to be had on delivery methods and access points as the way we work and live continue to evolve. The way the USO is funded was also touched on and this will be an area of concern for the industry as a whole, and a real challenge for Postcomm.

The post will always be an emotive issue but it’s important that any future debate considers all options, however far reaching, to ensure that the outcome really is the very best it can be for customers.

Postwatch are already in the process of carrying out extensive research on the value of the USO and will be at the forefront of this debate as it develops.

Labels: , ,

Sunday, June 24, 2007

A new way to protest

The Bexley and Bromley Conservatives in London have been campaigning against post office closures and they’ve made a youtube video which they have hosted on their website. The protest concerns a Crown office in Bromley which is proposed for franchising to WHSmith.

Full marks to them for using a new technology. A pity that they forgot to make representations to the Greater London Region of Postwatch.

In fact, nine Crown offices in London are currently the subject of consultations by Post Office Limited and members of the Greater London Regional Committee have visited all of the sites - including Bromley - and the Regional Chairman Roger Darlington has made appropriate written representations to POL.

Labels: ,

Thursday, June 21, 2007

European postal market liberalisation delayed

Following a vote on Monday night, the European Parliament Committee on Transport and Tourism (TRAN), overwhelmingly voted in support of a series of compromise amendments to the European Commission's proposals for a third Postal Services Directive - the latest set of proposals on the liberalisation of the European postal market.

The effects of the proposed amendments are numerous, and include delaying full liberalisation until 1 January 2011 for most member states, and until 1 January 2013 for newer member states and those with a particularly difficult topography. The previous proposals set a date of 1 January 2009 for full liberalisation.

The outcome of the proposals is still to be finalised, with the European Parliament having to vote on the new proposals in July. If the vote is passed, the Commission will then need to develop a common position to be considered by the Council in October and - in a best case scenario – be adopted by Parliament before the end of the year.

Postwatch is disappointed that it has been necessary to compromise in this way; we believe that member States have already had plenty of time to prepare for full market opening. However, we welcome the proposal to fix a firm date which will commit everyone to postal liberalisation.

Recently Jim Fitzpatrick, the Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Employment Relations and Postal Services, spoke about European liberalisation at the annual Postcomm Forum. A copy of his key-note speech can be found here.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, June 20, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (5)

Last week, Postwatch held a Network Change Training Conference. The event was opened and closed by our Chair Millie Banerjee.

She insisted that a key issue in the success of the programme would be the attitude of Postwatch and the attitude of Post Office Ltd and she explained that: “So far, working relationships have been excellent”. She underlined that Postwatch has no right of veto over closures but it does have a right to escalate an unconvincing case for closure. She was very clear that Postwatch has to maintain its independence and its integrity and the ways to do this are to be very transparent and to have effective communications. She insisted: “This programme is our legacy”.

Undoubtedly all Postwatch colleagues attending the conference left more informed and determined to do a difficult job in a committed and professional manner.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (4)

Last week, Postwatch held a Network Change Training Conference. This was addressed by Sue Huggins who is Programme Director Network Change at Post Office Ltd and a long-standing veteran at the business with some previous involvement in Urban Reinvention. She listed the differences between this programme and Urban Reinvention, However, she acknowledged how tough it would be: “We can do a difficult thing very sensitively”.

She told us that the present location of post offices is “a product of history and not design”, but she was adamant that there was not a predetermined outcome for the exercise other than the non-negotiable closure of 2,500 offices nationally: “We do not have a list. You have my word. There is no list”.

She explained that there would be about 50 Area Plans and shortly the exact number and sequencing would be decided. However, there will be no actual closures before January 2008.

Labels: ,

Monday, June 18, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (3)

Last week, Postwatch held a Network Change Training Conference. This was addressed by Paula Vennells who is Network Director at Post Office Ltd and a newcomer to POL coming from Whitbread. Her presentation had as its central aim to put the closure programme in the much wider context of fundamental restructuring and repositioning of POL in order to make it profitable by 2011 (taking account of the Government's Social Network Payment) – a clear requirement of Government.

This wider five-year programme goes by the name of “five2eleven” although, since we are now one year into the programme, it is now billed as “four2eleven”.

She set out the five reasons for business change:

  • customer visits are falling: 28M to 24M a week
  • the customer experience is worst than competitors
  • the decline in government services
  • new business areas so competitive
  • costs and losses are unsustainable

Then she set out the five key aims:

  • a clear brand and customer proposition
  • focus on four product pillars*
  • other modern and relevant channels
  • streamlining of operations
  • make the Post Office a great place to work

*mails & retail, financial services, telephony, Government services

Labels: ,

Friday, June 15, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (2)

The opening speaker at this week's Postwatch Network Change Conference was the DTI Minister for Post Jim Fitzpatrick who did not have far to travel since we were meeting in his building.

He described the conference as “an important event” and “a positive milestone”. He said that Postwatch has “a key role” and added “your role is critical”, while expressing full confidence in “the dedication and professionalism” of Postwatch in carrying out its role.

Usefully he emphasized that Government wishes the closures to be proportionate across the country.

Labels: ,

Thursday, June 14, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (1)

Today Postwatch held a unique event - a gathering of Council members, Headquarters staff, Regional Committee members, Regional staff, and newly-recruited Network Advisers - to discuss the organisation's role in the network change programme about to be launched by Post Office Ltd (POL). Following a Government consultation, the programme will involve 2,500 compensated office closures and 500 new outreach models.

The all-day conference was held at the Department of Trade & Industry and, as well as all the Postwatch people, the event was attended by the DTI Minister for posts and three of his officials plus senior members of POL's Network Change Team. In all, some 140 were present.

Over the next few days, we will blog on the main speeches and themes at this very successful event, so please keep visiting.

Labels: ,

The Universal Service debate – MPs have their say

Yesterday (13 June) MPs debated the future of the Universal Service Obligation (USO) in a Westminster Hall debate. The full transcript of the debate can be found here.

Several points were made by MPs taking part in the debate, including a general agreement that the USO was a vital part of the postal service, and was particularly important for residents and businesses in more remote parts of the UK.

MPs called for continued protection of the USO, particularly in light of increased competition following liberalisation of the postal market, and in light of falling mail volumes. Calls were also made for a review of the impact of the Postal Services Act 2000, and of the performances of Postcomm and Postwatch.

MPs debated the potential impact of zonal pricing being applied to bulk mail products following Royal Mail’s application to do so; suggesting any moves towards zonal pricing in any form within the postal market may be seen as “chipping away” at the USO.

The debate was secured by Alistair Carmichael MP, and was attended by approximately 15 MPs, including Jim Fitzpatrick, the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Trade and Industry.

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Postcomm (3): the USO

The afternoon section of this year's Postcomm London Forum, held earlier this week, consisted of a series of discussion panels. Postwatch's contribution came in the panel on the future of the universal service obligation.

Speaking for us, Council member Roger Darlington argued that there was no evidence of political or consumer wishes to make significant changes in the USO at the present time, but he acknowledged that falling mail volumes and loss of market share by Royal Mail was likely to make the funding of the USO increasingly problematic.

Labels: ,

Postcomm (2): zonal pricing

This week, as part of its fourth annual London Forum, Postcomm held a workshop on Royal Mail's proposals for a new system of zonal pricing.

A presentation was made by Postwatch Council member Judith Donovan, supported by Postwatch Council David Bland, which was strongly critical of the proposals.

You can find a summary of the event here.

Labels: ,

Postcomm (1): Annual Report

This week, the postal regulator Postcomm published its annual report.

You can access the report here.

Labels:

Thursday, June 07, 2007

Postal Strike

As expected CWU membership has supported their leadership’s call for strike action. This is certainly not the end of the process. The two sides in this dispute need to keep talking so as to find a way forward that does not risk damaging the industry and its customers that they both care about.

The record breaking delivery performance that has recently been achieved shows just how well the management and workforce can work together.

For now customers shouldn’t worry about mail they have or are about to post. If industrial action is called, notice will be given.

Labels: ,

Results in for the 2007 Postwatch Annual Customer Satisfaction Survey

This year has seen a fantastic response from the survey with an above average of 53% of surveys completed and returned. The only main criticism that Postwatch had from the survey was that we have limited powers and influence over Postal Operators.

The survey provides feedback on how well Postwatch has handled customer complaints along with maintaining the quality of work. The results are used for future training issues and improving our complaint handling standards.

Overview of results

84% of those surveyed were very/fairly satisfied with the way in which Postwatch handled their complaint
A fantastic 84% of customers would definitely/probably recommend Postwatch to a friend or relative

Wednesday, June 06, 2007

The Needs of Postal Users - Customer Survey

Postwatch, Postcomm and Royal Mail yesterday published the results of a joint research project, which was undertaken to determine the key needs of postal service stakeholders. A full copy of the results can be found here.

The research found that postal users were generally happy with present postal services, but felt that any reduction in the present levels of service was likely to be unfavourable. A range of postal attributes were analysed in the research, with results showing that all postal attributes tested were important to customers.

The research paid particular attention to collections and deliveries, showing that earlier deliveries and later final collections were felt to be beneficial to customers. The results also showed that respondents would not wish for collections or deliveries to be made any less than 6 days a week, as is presently required under the Universal Service Obligation.

The research will be used by Postwatch to inform policy decisions, and to allow a greater understanding of postal users needs.

Labels: ,

Recorded Signed For – do you know what you’re buying?

Royal Mail’s Recorded Signed for service has generated a number of complaints to Postwatch. Customers have told Postwatch that Royal Mail don’t always bother to get a signature when they deliver an item, so there’s often a lack of proof of delivery (copy of signatures) when requested by the sender, particularly where items have been sent in bulk to a company address.

Did you know that Items sent via the Recorded Signed for service, go through the same delivery channel as ordinary First and Second Class post and doesn’t guarantee a next-day delivery?

Recorded Signed for is not meant for sending valuables such as cash, jewellery, etc and the maximum compensation payable is £34. However, Postwatch believes that many customers use this service to send items of higher value, either to take advantage of the cheaper service or because of lack of advice at post offices.

What are your experiences of Recorded Signed For? Does it do what it says on the tin? Are post offices making sure that customers purchase the right service?

Labels: , ,

Zonal Pricing: who wins?

Postwatch has submitted its response to Postcomm's consultation on Zonal Pricing.

Postwatch understands the need and principle behind Zonal Pricing but this must be balanced with the potential impact on customers. The potential benefit of Zonal Pricing is outweighed by the potential disadvantages to customers, especially rural dwellers and competitors. Postwatch is not aware of any customer who has openly welcomed the proposals. Furthermore, Royal Mail may be damaging its own interests by potentially reducing mail volumes and revenues.

Based on the customer focused criteria, that the new system should not be introduced in a manner that avoids unreasonable changes for users of the services, we are concerned at the potential impact this initiative may have on:
- the future of the universal service,
- large mailers,
- mail volumes,
- competition,
- London, and
- rural dwellers (senders & recipients).

In addition, we have concerns surrounding:
- Potential zone anomalies,
- Cost reflectivity and revenue neutrality, and
- Communication and Implementation.

Postcomm will publish a further consultation in July/August 2007.

The full Postwatch response can be viewed here.

Labels: , ,

Monday, June 04, 2007

Latest quality of service results released by Royal Mail

Following the release by Royal Mail of its full-year quality of service results, Postwatch has undertaken a review of these results and found that once again improvements have been made in a number of areas.

Royal Mail’s quality of service is measured against 12 targets, and for the year 2006-07 Royal Mail met or exceeded 11 of these targets. In previous years Royal Mail has failed to achieve many of the set targets, so it is encouraging that the present levels of performance recorded by Royal Mail are good in almost all areas.

The headline figures from the report show that 94% of 1st class mail arrived next day (target 93%) and 98.9% of 2nd class mail arrived within 3 days (target 98.5%). The best performing postcode area in terms of 1st class mail was Derby, which managed to ensure 96.1% of 1st class mail arrived the next day after posting.

Standard Parcels continued to perform above target, with performance recorded at 94.5% (target 90%). This performance was the best annual performance for this product since standards of service measurements were introduced, although performance fell slightly from Quarter 3 of 2006-07.

Performance for Special Delivery for 2006-07 met its target of 99%, recording a performance of 99% for the period. This is encouraging, since Special Delivery is a premium Royal Mail product, and had frequently failed to achieve its target in the past.

In terms of Royal Mail achieving its Universal Service Obligation (USO), the quality of service results showed 99.92% of collection points are being served each day (target 99.9%), and 99.95% of delivery routes are completed each day (target 99.9%).

The only target Royal mail failed to meet for the year was the percentage of Postcode Areas (PCAs) hitting their delivery target of 91.5%. 116 of 118 PCAs met the target, with Exeter and Torquay missing the target by 0.3% and 0.1% respectively.

The overall picture painted by the quality of service results is encouraging. Postwatch is pleased to commend Royal Mail on its performance, and hopes the current high level of service continues.

Labels:

Friday, June 01, 2007

The best job in the world?

"Running a company is the best job in the world, it's the hardest job in the world, it's the loneliest job in the world and you can put a great team around you but, in the end, the buck stops in one place. And you think about it all the time."
The Chairman of Royal Mail, Allan Leighton, quoted in a profile in today's "Guardian" newspaper.

Labels: