Saturday, March 24, 2007

The mouse that roared

Earlier this week, the Consumers, Estate Agents and Redress Bill had its Second Reading in the House of Commons. This is the Bill that will merge Postwatch, Energywatch and the National Consumer Council into a single body to be called the new National Consumer Council.

In opening the debate, the Minister Ian McCartney stated:
"Some critics of those proposals have raised concerns about loss of expertise and loss of independence. Some have even suggested that the Government are creating this new body in order to silence criticism of Government action, on post offices in particular. Let me say now that our objective in bringing these bodies together is to create not a mouse too meek to challenge us, but a lion who will, I hope, roar on behalf of consumers. We do not want to weaken consumer representation, but to strengthen it. We do not want to lose valued expertise, but to build on it and make sure that all sectors benefit from it. A strong rope is made from intertwining different strands together. That is why we will create the new National Consumer Council."

Labels: , , ,

Friday, March 23, 2007

New number; new date

The DTI Minister for postal services Jim Fitzpatrick today advised the House of Commons on the latest figure for the total number of submissions on the Government consultation document on post office closures. Also he revised the previous intention to publish the Government decision document by the end of March.

He said: "The Government’s consultation on the post office network ended on 8 March. We have received more than 2,500 representations, and are grateful to those who took time to participate in the process. We are giving full consideration to the comments received and hope to be able to announce our final decisions in May."

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, March 22, 2007

Price Control to be reopened after just one year?

The regulator, Postcomm, has today started a consultation based on two proposals from Royal Mail and one from TNT.

Postwatch is concerned that Royal Mail’s proposals will have a detrimental effect on customers. It appears that aspects of the 4-year price control for Royal Mail are being re-opened just a year after being agreed. Royal Mail could have rejected the deal but accepted it and immediately put up 1st class stamp prices by 2 pence.

At first glance it seems Royal Mail is now seeking to both reduce the range of prices that competitors can offer and to rebalance its prices so as to offer cheaper ones to business customers whilst increasing the price of stamps.

Postwatch will review business cases submitted by the Royal Mail and TNT when they are published on 30 March and will comment further after that.

Tuesday, March 20, 2007

A lot of mail for the DTI

The Department of Trade & Industry (DTI) has received over 2,300 responses to its public consultation on the future of the Post Office network which ended on Thursday 8 March. In addition, the Department also received a number of local petitions and postcard/stock letter campaigns.

Previously the Department has insisted that it intends to pubish a Government decision document by the end of March, meaning that a mere three weeks would be taken to consider all these responses - the Postwatch one made 99 recommendations - and then consult Ministers and finally draft and publish a final document.

However, this week, in response to a Parliamentary Question, DTI Minister for posts Jim Fitzpatrick simply said: "We are currently reviewing the response and will be publishing our conclusions in due course".

If the Government's decision statement is not published in the next three weeks, it will be caught by the purdah period which applies to local elections and the statement will have to be postponed until May.

The DTI lost out in a judicial review of its poor consultation process over the energy review. It will not want to repeat this mistake.

Sunday, March 18, 2007

What's happening to direct mail?

Until recently, substantial growth in direct mail volumes has continued to drive year-on-year growth in total mail volumes in the UK, but most recently letter growth seems to have faltered and the future of mail volumes was one of the main issues raised in Postcomm's recent Strategy Review. In the last few days, Royal Mail has issued three media releases on direct mail, each of which appears to present an encouraging picture but the big picture looks somewhat different.

Building societies’ use of direct mail has increased by 18.8 per cent; the charity sector’s use of direct mail has increased by 9.1 per cent: and the government sector’s use of direct mail has increased by six per cent. Good news? Well, yes - but each of the three media releases reveals in the final paragraph that: "Overall direct mail volumes during October to December 2006 experienced a slight fall with 958.69 million items sent compared with one billion mail pieces during the same period in 2005."

Royal Mail tries to present this as some kind of achievement: "This is a result of companies across all sectors improving their targeting to create even more relevant and personal offers for their customers and prospects."

The hard truth then is that direct mail - so long the powerful engine of growth of overall mail volumes - is no longer rising, but actually falling.

Thursday, March 15, 2007

Judicial review - a long and winding road

Last week a long and expensive legal journey came to an end. The Court of Appeal gave what will be the final interpretation of a Postcomm scheme for compensation by Royal Mail to bulk mailers for failures in its quality of service.

In fact Royal Mail's quality of service has improved a great deal since the case arose. The year at the heart of the case was 2003/4, when quality of service was far lower than it is now. And the words at the heart of the case were 'is' and 'where' - two of the commonest words in the English language, which still took some of the sharpest legal minds in the English legal system to interpret.

For the record, Postwatch's view of the meaning of 'is', and Royal Mail's view of the word 'where', won the day. And now that this is settled, the hope must be that the bulk mailers will, without further delay or fuss, receive what they are due according to the court's interpretation of the compensation scheme.

Calling Callers Offices, Dialling Delivery Offices

Calls to Callers Offices and Delivery Offices are now routed through a call management system for three-quarters of address points within the UK, meaning callers are directed to the right facility for their enquiry more easily.

Royal Mail have also informed Postwatch that they are continuing to improve physical access and facilities in Callers Offices for disabled customers, through ensuring hearing loops are fitted and disabled parking bays are provided wherever possible. Postwatch are pleased that Royal Mail are improving both physical and virtual access to Callers Offices, but are keen to ensure that all customers benefit from improved access, and that any continuing access problems are addressed quickly when discovered.

28 Days Earlier

Royal Mail has agreed to Postwatch’s request for an extension to the notification period for changes to Callers Offices’ opening hours. Royal Mail will now give 28 days notice to Postwatch, and place notices up at any affected Callers Offices 28 days before the proposed changes come into effect.

Postwatch feels that 28 days notice, as opposed to the initial 7 days, will provide customers and itself sufficient time to make objections if required. Postwatch do however, strongly recommend to customers that if they feel changes to Callers Offices’ services are likely to be detrimental to them, they should complain to Royal Mail during the 28 day notification period, and inform Postwatch of their concerns.

Wednesday, March 14, 2007

Post, Penalties and Protection Procedures

The High Court has upheld a £9.62m financial penalty levied against Royal Mail for its failure to follow mail protection procedures.

The penalty was proposed after Postcomm, the industry regulator, reviewed Royal Mail’s mail integrity procedures and found some important features were not being applied across the business during 2004/05. One key area where Royal Mail was found to be at fault was in the recruitment and training processes for temporary staff; an area which we understand Royal Mail have subsequently made significant improvements to.

Royal Mail accepted the failures highlighted by Postcomm, but appealed against the size of the financial penalty imposed. The High Court, however, upheld the size of the fine, ruling that it accurately reflect the loss suffered by customers from Royal Mail’s failure to protect mail in its care.

Postwatch views the penalty as being a strong reminder to Royal Mail that the integrity of the mail is a very important issue to customers, and that every effort should be made to ensure the safe and correct delivery of all customers’ mail.

Monday, March 12, 2007

Making the case for post office customers

The DTI’s consultation on its proposals for the future of the post office network has now closed. Postwatch has drawn together a detailed and comprehensive response, making 99 recommendations, and the full consultation response can be read here.

Postwatch is concerned that:

• Government has proposed 2,500 closures, but the case for these have not been fully made
• the proposals do not go far enough to create a viable post office network
• the access criteria are confusing and ambiguous- they fail to offer sufficient protection, particularly for urban deprived areas
• other local factors should be considered wherever Post Office Ltd proposes individual changes to the network, for example traveling time to the nearest alternative and local socio-economic factors
• the social role is welcomed, but needs to be articulated more explicitly
• Postwatch is set to be abolished midway through the programme, which could damage the programme’s effectiveness
• Local consultation is key, and local consultations should last for 12 weeks

Government is set to announce its intentions before the end of the month, and Postwatch looks forward to continuing discussions with the DTI to achieve the optimum solution for customers who rely on access to post office services.

A danger of rubber stamping

The "Financial Times" reports today that, by the deadline of last Thursday, the Department of Trade & Industry had received some 1,100 submissions on its consultation document proposing the closure of some 2,500 local post offices nationwide. The Postwatch submission is a particularly comprehensive document that makes no less than 99 measured recommendations.

Yet the Government is apparently planning to consider all these submissions, further deliberate on its proposals, and draft and publish a more detailed decision document by the end of March. The closure programme is going to be complex and controversial enough without stakeholders and communities feeling that the consultation process was simply a rubber stamping of the original proposals.

Wednesday, March 07, 2007

Zonal Pricing

Royal Mail has submitted a revised application for zonal pricing following discussions with Postcomm. The change is to the definition of the zones.

Zones now range from A (business district, i.e. very high density)through to D (very low density). There will also be a Greater London zone (referred to as London) which is defined to comprise approximately the area within the M25 motorway. Discounts will be given to bulk business mail customers for deliveries to higher density zones, where delivery costs are lower than average, and surcharges made for deliveries to low density zones, where delivery costs are higher than average.

According to Royal Mail, a London zone (covering AL, BR, CR, DA E, EC,EN, HA, IG, KT, N, NW, RM, SE, SM, SW, UB, TW, W, WC, WD) has been created to reflect the cost differences between locations that are not caused by geographical factors but by the amount that it costs to supply the relevant resource, principally pay rates, but also inward Mail Centre costs, indoor delivery office work and other delivery
office costs.

Postcomm is continuing to analyse Royal Mail's costing data and is expected to make a decision within the next 2 weeks on whether it has information of sufficient quality to start the 9 month consultation clock. Royal Mail has targeted April 2008 for introduction, however, this date is becoming more unrealistic as the weeks pass by.

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

Stamp of Approval?

Today the House of Commons Select Committee Committee on Trade & Industry published its report "Stamp of Approval? The future of the Post Office network".

The Chairman of the Committee, Mr Peter Luff, said

“We believe that post offices are more than commercial enterprises, playing a vital role in communities for both individuals and businesses, especially in rural and deprived urban areas. So we support the Government’s aim of sustaining the network. The proposals also mark the beginning of the end of a period of considerable uncertainty for sub­postmasters.

“We have been told that to be worthy of the name the network needs about 12,000 post offices, but it is not clear how the Government arrived at this figure. We are concerned to ensure that the right decisions are taken in relation to individual post offices, and that those left after the restructuring continue to exist and, where possible, become commercially viable. We need more detail from the Government and Post Office Limited before we can be sure that the restructured network can be sustained. And we are particularly keen that sub-postmasters should not be constrained from developing new products to strengthen their business.”

The Committee expresses reservations about aspects of the Government’s proposals and calls for a number of changes to the Government’s approach. It notes that:

“It is not clear whether the suspiciously round figure of 2,500 closures was derived from a proper analysis of what was needed to provide a national network, or simply represents the maximum number that could be funded from the resources provided by HM Treasury. However, it is clear that the network of “about 12,000” post offices referred to by the Secretary of State takes into account only compensated closures: the Government’s proposals set no numerical limit on uncompensated ones.”

The report also calls for the Government to reconsider its timetable for the intended merger of Postwatch with two other consmer bodies since, as currently planned, Postwatch would cease to exist right in the middle of the closure progamme.