Friday, November 30, 2007

Select Committee enquiry into post office closures

In a Westminster Hall debate by MPs this week on the programme of 2,500 post office closures, Peter Luff, Chairman of the relevant Select Committee, stated:

"It is a great pleasure that the swansong debate of the Select Committee on Trade and Industry, now the Select Committee on Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, should be so popular. I am informed by the Speaker’s Office that this is the most popular ever Westminster Hall debate on a Select Committee report."

"The new Select Committee will launch an inquiry early in the new year into the progress of the post office closure process. We will have hearings, probably in late January or early February, and will revisit the process then, because this matter is obviously of deep concern to many colleagues."

Labels:

Friday, November 23, 2007

Suspension of Post Office closure programme

Postwatch welcomes the suspension of the post office closure programme during the London mayoral and local election campaigns. This was expected and is in keeping with usual practice before elections.

The closure of a local post office is a sensitive issue. Postwatch is pleased that the case for closure will be considered on its merits and that those involved will not be distracted by political campaigning.

There will be no public consultations or closure announcements between 7th April and 2nd May 2008.

Current public consultations can be found at the Post Office network change programme official site.

Labels:

Monday, November 12, 2007

2,500 Post Offices will close

It is being reported by the media that Post Office Limited’s (POL) post office closure consultations are a sham. This is because if a post office is saved from closure, POL may put forward another to close in its place.

The consultation process is not perfect but it is not about whether a closure programme should take place. The Government have already decided closures are needed, and will happen by the end of 2008. POL’s consultations are about which post offices should close. They need local authorities, MPs and customers to engage with the process to help ensure the right offices are closed.

Unfortunately, by labelling the process a sham there is a risk consultees will be put off from giving their comments. That would be a far greater shame, and risks a worse outcome.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, November 08, 2007

CWU and Pensioners demonstrate against post office closures

This week, the Communication Workers Union and the National Pensioners Convention held a joint demonstration outside Trafalgar Square Post Office against closures and franchising.

Demonstrators were concerned about the Government’s decision to fund the closure of 2,500 sub-post offices nationwide by the end of 2008, and Post Office Ltd’s decision to enter into franchise partnerships with WHSmith at 70 locations. Postwatch came under criticism too, with Kate Hoey MP accusing us of not doing enough to oppose the changes.

Postwatch wants a post office network which is sustainable and not subject to unplanned closures, and which allows customers reasonable access to services. We recognise that customers’ habits are changing and that the network must change with them. Because of this, we are scrutinising Post Office Ltd’s proposals before every public consultation of the closure programme. Our aim is to minimise customer inconvenience and encourage local input on proposals.

While we understand customers’ concerns about franchising, it is a means of continuing to provide services, often with increased opening hours. Moreover, by reducing operational costs in this way, Post Office Ltd should be better able to create much-needed stability for its network.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, October 02, 2007

Start of consultations on post office closures

Today is the starting day for the first public consultations on post office closures. The Government has charged Post Office Ltd with closing up to 2,500 post offices throughout the UK (500 of which will be replaced by ‘outreach’ services).

Kent, East Midlands, East Yorkshire and North Lincolnshire are the first affected areas, with 180 proposed closures and a further 35 existing branches proposed to be replaced by outreach services. Consultations for these areas finish on 12 November. Postwatch will be active during consultation scrutinising Post Office Ltd’s proposals, and ensuring customers give their comments. Our final views will be available on our website at the end of consultation.

Every part of the UK will be affected by the programme, and Postwatch urges customers to find out when local consultation will take place in their area, and to get involved.

Find out when public consultations will take place, and full details of the first three consultations here.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

Timetable for consultations on post office closures published

Post Office Ltd has released details on its website of when it will consult locally throughout the UK on post office closures. Go here for more information.

The Government has decided that up to 2,500 closures will take place in 2008. To that end, Post Office Ltd will divide the UK into about 50 ‘area plans’. Each area plan will be made up of a number of parliamentary constituencies and be subject to six weeks public consultation. The first public consultation –covering Kent – starts on 17 September 2007.

This is a major change - every parliamentary constituency in the UK will be affected – and it is important that customers engage in the process. Find out when Post Office Ltd will bring forward proposals in your area; then, when public consultation is underway, look out for more information at branches, or contact Post Office Ltd.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

The challenge to Postwatch

Nationwide Post Office Limited is currently in the process of franchising some 70 Crown offices into WHSmith outlets and, over the next 18 months, some 2,500 offices will actually close (although around 500 will be replaced by outreach arrangements).

A taste of the challenge faced by Postwatch as these exercises roll out came from a public meeting this week in Fulham in London when the local (Conservative) Council organised a protest meeting against the intended franchising of the Farm Lane Crown office to the WHSmith outlet in nearby North End Road. The meeting was addressed by Postwatch's Greater London Chairman Roger Darlington who predictably received a tough reception since Postwatch cannot veto such a proposal and can understand the case for franchising. You can read an account of the meeting from a local (Conservative) councillor here.

Some of the many issues which came up in Fulham - which will certainly come up elsewhere - were as follows:
  • Customers find it hard to understand how a Crown office can be loss-making when it is seemingly so busy. More explanation is necessary about the falling number of transactions and the low margin on most transactions and, if POL does feel able to give more local financial data, that would be very helpful.
  • Customers cannot understand how, if POL cannot make money from a particular office, then a franchisee like WHSmith apparently can. Again more explanation is necessary, this time about the different business model which franchisees operate, including shared property costs, lower staff costs and greater footfall.
  • Residents find it hard to envisage how the facilities of a Crown office can be fitted inside an already full retail outlet like a WHSmith shop. It would be really helpful if they could be shown actual layouts and plans with full details of the number of counters and floor space.
  • Most controversially people don't understand why the consumer watchdog does not simply oppose any franchising or closure proposal when it is clear that all those at the protest meeting do not want it. It is tough but we have to explain that such hard decisions are likely to make the overall network more sustainable and the alternative is continued, unplanned closures such as we have seen for decades.
  • Finally there are constant demands that the post office network should not be required to behave commercially and should be subsidized by government with much party political posturing against the present government. Postwatch is of course politically neutral and can only operate within the context set by the government of the day. But we need to point out that there is in fact a measure of subsidy to the post office network (the social network payment of £150M a year) and the forthcoming closure programme has been reluctantly accepted as necessary by the cross-party Select Committee on Trade & Industry.

Labels: ,

Sunday, June 24, 2007

A new way to protest

The Bexley and Bromley Conservatives in London have been campaigning against post office closures and they’ve made a youtube video which they have hosted on their website. The protest concerns a Crown office in Bromley which is proposed for franchising to WHSmith.

Full marks to them for using a new technology. A pity that they forgot to make representations to the Greater London Region of Postwatch.

In fact, nine Crown offices in London are currently the subject of consultations by Post Office Limited and members of the Greater London Regional Committee have visited all of the sites - including Bromley - and the Regional Chairman Roger Darlington has made appropriate written representations to POL.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, June 20, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (5)

Last week, Postwatch held a Network Change Training Conference. The event was opened and closed by our Chair Millie Banerjee.

She insisted that a key issue in the success of the programme would be the attitude of Postwatch and the attitude of Post Office Ltd and she explained that: “So far, working relationships have been excellent”. She underlined that Postwatch has no right of veto over closures but it does have a right to escalate an unconvincing case for closure. She was very clear that Postwatch has to maintain its independence and its integrity and the ways to do this are to be very transparent and to have effective communications. She insisted: “This programme is our legacy”.

Undoubtedly all Postwatch colleagues attending the conference left more informed and determined to do a difficult job in a committed and professional manner.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (4)

Last week, Postwatch held a Network Change Training Conference. This was addressed by Sue Huggins who is Programme Director Network Change at Post Office Ltd and a long-standing veteran at the business with some previous involvement in Urban Reinvention. She listed the differences between this programme and Urban Reinvention, However, she acknowledged how tough it would be: “We can do a difficult thing very sensitively”.

She told us that the present location of post offices is “a product of history and not design”, but she was adamant that there was not a predetermined outcome for the exercise other than the non-negotiable closure of 2,500 offices nationally: “We do not have a list. You have my word. There is no list”.

She explained that there would be about 50 Area Plans and shortly the exact number and sequencing would be decided. However, there will be no actual closures before January 2008.

Labels: ,

Monday, June 18, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (3)

Last week, Postwatch held a Network Change Training Conference. This was addressed by Paula Vennells who is Network Director at Post Office Ltd and a newcomer to POL coming from Whitbread. Her presentation had as its central aim to put the closure programme in the much wider context of fundamental restructuring and repositioning of POL in order to make it profitable by 2011 (taking account of the Government's Social Network Payment) – a clear requirement of Government.

This wider five-year programme goes by the name of “five2eleven” although, since we are now one year into the programme, it is now billed as “four2eleven”.

She set out the five reasons for business change:

  • customer visits are falling: 28M to 24M a week
  • the customer experience is worst than competitors
  • the decline in government services
  • new business areas so competitive
  • costs and losses are unsustainable

Then she set out the five key aims:

  • a clear brand and customer proposition
  • focus on four product pillars*
  • other modern and relevant channels
  • streamlining of operations
  • make the Post Office a great place to work

*mails & retail, financial services, telephony, Government services

Labels: ,

Friday, June 15, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (2)

The opening speaker at this week's Postwatch Network Change Conference was the DTI Minister for Post Jim Fitzpatrick who did not have far to travel since we were meeting in his building.

He described the conference as “an important event” and “a positive milestone”. He said that Postwatch has “a key role” and added “your role is critical”, while expressing full confidence in “the dedication and professionalism” of Postwatch in carrying out its role.

Usefully he emphasized that Government wishes the closures to be proportionate across the country.

Labels: ,

Thursday, June 14, 2007

Network Change Training Conference (1)

Today Postwatch held a unique event - a gathering of Council members, Headquarters staff, Regional Committee members, Regional staff, and newly-recruited Network Advisers - to discuss the organisation's role in the network change programme about to be launched by Post Office Ltd (POL). Following a Government consultation, the programme will involve 2,500 compensated office closures and 500 new outreach models.

The all-day conference was held at the Department of Trade & Industry and, as well as all the Postwatch people, the event was attended by the DTI Minister for posts and three of his officials plus senior members of POL's Network Change Team. In all, some 140 were present.

Over the next few days, we will blog on the main speeches and themes at this very successful event, so please keep visiting.

Labels: ,

Friday, May 18, 2007

2,500 Post Offices to close

Postwatch recognise that yesterday’s announcement by the government that 2,500 post offices will be closed over the next 18 months will be unpopular and worry some customers. However, the reality of the situation is that without severe pruning the whole network was in jeopardy.

It is without doubt in the best interests of customers that post office closures are planned rather than unplanned. If the government had not taken its decision we fear there would have been a large number of unplanned closures that could have resulted in gaps in the network.

Postwatch is not, of course, happy with all aspects of the government’s announcement. However, we have to recognise that decisions have been taken and rather than try to get them changed our efforts have to be fully directed towards getting the best possible outcome for customers. In many ways it will be up to Postwatch to ensure local consultations on area plans are meaningful and that proper attention is paid to points raised.

Postwatch is particularly pleased that the government have agreed that local factors like public transport links, the impact on the local economy and demographics will be assessed when applying the basic distance based access criteria.

No-one at this stage knows which post offices will close.

Labels: , , ,

Friday, March 23, 2007

New number; new date

The DTI Minister for postal services Jim Fitzpatrick today advised the House of Commons on the latest figure for the total number of submissions on the Government consultation document on post office closures. Also he revised the previous intention to publish the Government decision document by the end of March.

He said: "The Government’s consultation on the post office network ended on 8 March. We have received more than 2,500 representations, and are grateful to those who took time to participate in the process. We are giving full consideration to the comments received and hope to be able to announce our final decisions in May."

Labels: , , ,