Thursday, November 30, 2006

(What) Time for the Last Post?

The final collection times made by Royal Mail are becoming earlier in some areas of the UK. Postwatch has been monitoring changes to final collection times across the UK, and has recorded over 6000 cases where final collection times have changed. Of theses changes, over 5000 have resulted in collection times becoming earlier. The changes have predominantly occurred in rural areas, where it is not uncommon for the final collection time to be brought forward by 7 hours (16:00 to 09:00). Although changes in urban areas are generally smaller, even a one hour change from 17:30 to 16:30 can have a large impact on the working patterns of businesses.

Since the introduction of a single daily delivery in 2003-04, delivery times are also getting later for many customers. Although Royal Mail has no obligation to deliver by a specific time each day, they aim to complete deliveries by 2pm in urban areas and 3pm in rural areas. However, Postwatch is aware that mail is often delivered after these times.

The problems caused by later delivery times and earlier collection times can be large. An individual or business wishing to respond to correspondence in the same day will have a shorter time to do so, and may even face the prospect of mail being collected locally before they have their daily delivery, making same-day replies impossible. Later delivery times and earlier collection times may force businesses to either alter their working patterns, or cause delays in mail based correspondence.

Postcomm is currently undertaking a consultation on collection and delivery times in order to evaluate the effects of these changes. Postwatch has consulted its various stakeholders for their opinions on this important issue and will respond to the Postcomm consultation accordingly.

Christmas in Comm-ing

Postwatch welcomes the fact that Royal Mail will undertake a follow up communications campaign in the run up to Christmas to remind customers of the recent changeover to Pricing in Proportion (PIP).

An overview of what Royal Mail is covering with its Christmas communications campaign includes:
press
point of sale material
size guides
PR
web

Posters have been produced for POL Branches and Callers Offices

Royal Mail has also re-printed 750,000 size guides to make sure it has sufficient levels in POL branches. These will also be available from 08456 113 113 number and to order through www.royalmail.com

A first class performance

Royal Mail’s performance from April to September was very good across the board and the company is well on course to comfortably beat all the yearly cumulative targets in it licence. For example 94.4% of 1st class mail arrived next day (target 93%) and 99.1% of second class arrived within 3 days (target 98.5%).

This is very good news for customers who can now be confident they are buying/receiving good levels of service.

Postwatch criticised Royal Mail when its performance was poor and has no hesitation in now congratulating the management and workforce for a job being well done. Competition has clearly spurred the company to get its act together.

Isn’t it good to once again have a Royal Mail we can be proud of?

Tuesday, November 28, 2006

Basic banking: the post office benefits

New findings from the National Consumer Council highlight the fact that only 2 in 5 basic bank accounts can be accessed over the post office counter.

Read the full report here.

The NCC’s plan for inclusive banking recognises the need for all 6.5 million accounts to be accessible at post offices. This is important for financial inclusion, but also to ensure the sustainability of the post office network.

It’s worth remembering that in rural areas, 78% of post offices are located in settlements without a nearby bank.

And without the income that financial services bring to the Post Office network, the number of post offices would be under even greater pressure - affecting access to postal services as well as access to cash.

Friday, November 24, 2006

Where does Aunt Joan live?

Postwatch's top tips for getting the most from your post this Christmas are:-

  • Only choose cards for posting that fit the new 'standard letter' size. See link to our Pricing in Proportion guide.

  • Use the full postal address including the post code. Millions of cards are undelivered every year because the address is incomplete. You cannot expect Royal Mail to know where Aunt Joan lives unless you tell them!

  • Add a return address to your cards. This will show you which friends have moved, and even perhaps prompt those that have not to send one to you.

  • Use 2nd class stamps. The basic 2nd class stamp costs only 23 pence, 9 pence less than 1st class.

  • Please post early. There is no need for a last minute rush.

Wednesday, November 22, 2006

Post office problems with new pricing structure

Three months after Royal Mail introduced its new pricing structure, Pricing in Proportion, Postwatch research released this week shows post offices are charging one in every eight customers incorrectly – a major concern in the run-up to Christmas, the year’s busiest posting period.

Details are available on the Postwatch website and an article appeared in today’s Daily Mail. In the article, Royal Mail is quoted as claiming the Postwatch research involved sending ‘unusual’ items.

The research involved sending three types of mail – a letter, a greetings card with badge, and a CD – hardly uncommon items that that post office staff would have trouble dealing with!

Over Christmas, when millions of greeting cards and presents of all shapes and sizes will be sent, it is vital that customers not only understand the new pricing system, but post office staff do as well.

It is, of course, understandable that with such a major change, some customers will not adapt as quickly as others. To that end, we welcome Royal Mail’s commitment to extend its amnesty on surcharges for items with underpaid postage until at least after Christmas.

Monday, November 20, 2006

Post offices post-POCA

The Treasury Select Committee report issued this weekend calls for joined-up thinking on the post office network, and suggests the Treasury should develop a clear blueprint for the role of the post office with appropriate financial support.

The Committee calls for a cross-departmental approach to post office issues, indicating the importance of the post office to the government’s financial inclusion agenda. It also recommends that the Government work with Post Office Ltd to introduce a successor to the Post Office Card Account, offering greater functionality to maximise financial inclusion.

Postwatch is concerned about the impact of the withdrawal of the Card Account on the future viability of the network. When government consults within weeks on its preferred options for the network’s future, it is vital that we get a sustainable plan for our post office services. All government departments with an interest in the network should be working through the MISC 33 Cabinet Committee to ensure that we get a joined-up approach to providing and funding the UK’s future post office provision.

The future of POCA

John McFall, the Labour MP who headed a House of Commons Treasury Select Committee inquiry into banking for poorer citizens, has told "The Times" newspaper: “Treating bank account-holders like second-class citizens by denying access to branch counters causes exclusion and reduces the opportunities for holders to become further integrated with the financial services sector.”

He noted that plans to replace a Post Office Card Account (POCA) with a new product by 2010 had not been handled well by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP). About 1.2 million people who do not have access to another account use a POCA to receive benefits and the DWP must ensure that plans for a successor product are in place well before 2010, Mr McFall said. Banks have provided £180 million to fund POCAs over five years, but the funding will end in 2008.

"Times" article here and Select Committee report here.

Friday, November 17, 2006

Looking to the future....

Postwatch has today published its response to Postcomm’s Strategy Review. This document outlines our vision for the postal market and details our position on key areas such as universal service provision, competition, deregulation and separation.

Our vision for the UK postal market is of a dynamic and thriving industry in which all customers benefit from a universal level of provision, an overall decline in prices in real terms, improving quality of service, greater choice of provider and products, and increasing innovation.

The main messages in our submission – to both Postcomm and any successor to Postwatch – are as follows:

· Social consumers, and most especially vulnerable consumers, need the universal service obligation to be protected. This does not mean that its scope and funding cannot be reviewed in the light of changing circumstances over the next decade, but it does mean that the USO must reflect properly-determined consumer needs and be adequately funded.

· Royal Mail has responded to the new competitive environment by commencing a programme of rebalancing of tariffs in order to achieve more cost-reflectivity. While we understand the logic of aligning prices more closely to costs, we believe that this has to be done in a phased manner in order that services remain affordable to all consumers.

· Competition has already started to reduce Royal Mail's market share and this has happened at a time when overall mail volumes have ceased to rise and look likely to experience a gradual but sustained decline. While we certainly favour a level playing field, reduced barriers to entry and greater competition, such changes must be introduced gradually with proper regard to the impact on social customers and the implications for the funding of the USO and in a manner that ensures that competitors are not undermined before they have properly established themselves.

· Although the consultation document does not mention the post office network, we see this network as an integral part of the delivery of postal services and therefore an essential part of the strategy review. The Government, the regulator and other relevant stakeholders need to form a common strategic view of what social outcomes are desired from the post office network and how those can be achieved. It is essential to ensure reasonable accessible to postal services by all customers, but with a particular focus on the needs of vulnerable customers.

· Separation is a term often used very loosely and the idea is sometimes seen as the easy or obvious route to a more competitive framework. However, we believe that it is absolutely essential to define precisely what problem one is seeking to address before considering whether one of the many forms of separation might be a net advantage to the market as a whole and to consumers in particular.

· Given that competition is so new and fragile and that the postal market has so many differences from other regulated markets, we see a continued need for a sector-specific regulator and indeed sector-specific expertise in consumer representation (wherever that might be located organisationally). The regulator needs to make decisions based on evidence, be transparent in decision-making, and work closely with all stakeholders including the statutory representative of postal consumers.

We expect that this stage of Postcomm's strategy review is the beginning of a dialogue and more thinking by the regulator, prior to the determination of some specific policies, and we stand ready to play a full part in a continuation of this important dialogue on the future of postal regulation, so that we collectively achieve the best outcome for consumers.

A new phase

The Consumers, Estate Agents and Redress Bill - which will abolish Postwatch -received its First Reading in the House of Lords yesterday.
The First Reading of any Bill is a formal matter involving no information and no debate. A date for Second Reading - when the main principles of the Bill will be debated by peers - has now been set of 4 December.

The Bill will bring about a merger of Postwatch and Energywatch with the National Consumer Council into a new body provisionally called Consumer Voice. The new body is expected to come into operation early in 2008.

Thursday, November 16, 2006

Post Office awards

Congratulations to the winners of the 2006 Best Post Office Awards announced today.

We’re particularly pleased to see the Hungerford Rd post office in Crewe, Cheshire named Best Overall Branch. Given the inevitable media attention on rural offices, it’s a timely reminder that the problems affecting the rural network are also very real ones for post offices in deprived urban and urban locations.

Postwatch is working hard to support the network in both rural and urban locations, and its worth remembering that its largely down to Postwatch that the Government will consult on both the rural and deprived urban network soon.

In the zone

Royal Mail is intending to apply to Postcomm, the regulator, for permission to price their bulk mail products zonally.

This would mean that large mailers would be charged different prices for their mail depending on where it was been sent. The measure is proposed to be delivery point density, which will in the main part lead to city centres being cheaper to mail to, whereas rural areas would become more expensive.

Before Postcomm will consider the formal application they must have sufficient information of good quality from Royal Mail which will clearly demonstrate that zonal pricing will be revenue neutral, cost reflective and not inhibit competition. This stage has yet to be reached, however when it is there will be a nine month timeline before Postcomm make a decision.

On first glance it seems that this system will disadvantage those in rural areas, however there may be a drop in the amount of unaddressed mail delivered to these areas – which some people tell us will be a benefit.

You can see the initial briefing on zonal pricing from Postcomm here

Banking on the future of the Post Office Network

When talking about the future of post offices, Postwatch's remit is very much focused on the accessibility, availability, and quality of postal services. However, from our discussions with stakeholders such as Age Concern, the National Consumer Council and the W.I. we know the important role the post office network plays in facilitating financial inclusion. Indeed, without the income that financial services bring to the Post Office network, the number of post offices would be under even greater pressure - affecting access to postal services as well as access to cash.

First Direct has announced that it is going to start charging some current account customers for their service - and customers on lower than average incomes at that. At least one other financial institution is refusing to rule out similar charges.

With this risk, why does the Treasury's financial inclusion goal focus solely on access to bank accounts, a goal that is driving the development of the product to replace the ill-fated Post Office card account?

UK citizens must be able to choose where they keep and access their money, and that choice should include access at post offices - as recommended in an Early Day Motion tabled this week.

Wednesday, November 15, 2006

Safer neighbourhoods, sustaining post offices

We were pleased to see that Post Office Ltd has developed a partnership with another police force to deliver basic services whilst sharing costs. People in Greater Manchester can now pick up safety advice alongside their postage stamps, postal orders and pensions thanks to a new initiative that sees post offices in the county getting a designated police officer.

The scheme follows existing partnerships between Post Office Ltd and police forces in Norfolk, Dyfed Powys and in Scotland, which provide valuable additional opportunities for remote rural subpostmasters.

Postwatch welcomes such moves by Post Office Ltd to work with local service providers. The organisation cannot stand still whilst waiting for the government's long-promised consultation on the future of rural and deprived urban post offices.

A very big omelette

In her opening of Parliament speech today The Queen announced that there would be a Consumers Bill which will strengthen consumer advocacy. Tomorrow's papers will report that this involves the merger of Postwatch and Energywatch with the National Consumer Council. You cannot make an omelette without breaking eggs and you cannot merge public bodies without abolishing the old ones.

Postal customers should take some comfort from the government's wish to 'strengthen' consumer advocacy and not be overly concerned about Postwatch being abolished. Postwatch will do all it can to make sure the new body will be able to do an even better job on behalf of consumers. Postwatch and its successor will certainly have a key role in reviewing proposals to close, merge or move post offices.

Very Special Delivery?

There is just over a month left to respond to the consultation Postcomm has published on a proposed new Royal Mail sevice, Special Delivery High Value.

Royal Mail wish to exclude valuable items, such as cash and jewellery from the Special Delivery Next Day service and introduce Special Delivery High Value to cover these. This would allow customers to post items of value and to claim compensation for lost or damaged high value items. The new service would be at higher postage rates than currently charged.

Royal Mail argues that it needs to make these changes in order to help ensure that its staff are safer when delivering high value items.

Postcomm are consulting on the proposals, a copy of the consultation document can be seen here

Tuesday, November 14, 2006

The problems with POCA

"The Association of Credit Unions is optimistic about a deal for one huge credit union to offer accounts to all the low-paid through post offices; but it needs a change in the law. Post Office accounts are essential as there are no banks in poor wards. If the government does close savings facilities in post offices, ignore all future pieties about 'local community'. However, present Post Office card accounts are dreadful: they only take in benefits, they won't take pay cheques, they don't do direct debits for bills, they have no credit facility, nor even a debit card, and they only allow one withdrawal a week after queuing up."
Writing in today's "Guardian", Polly Toynbee has an article which puts the problem of poor savers into a wider context than the current debate about the collapse of Farepak.

Monday, November 13, 2006

Roger nominated for an award

After discovering that Royal Mail is launching a First Class People award, the "Barry and District News" has started a campaign to encourage their readers to nominate local postman Mr Roger Annies who was in trouble earlier this year with his advice to customers on his round about how to opt out of Royal Mail's door-to-door service. The campaign has already received national attention.

Postwatch makes no comment on Mr Annies' action or on the local newspaper campaign, but we believe that customers should be able to make an informed choice about whether or not to receive unsolicited mail, whether addressed or unaddressed. You can find our advice here.

Friday, November 10, 2006

Postwatch responds to the Delivery Exception consultation

The Universal Service Obligation (USO) requires Royal Mail to provide one delivery and one collection (at every delivery/collection point) ever working day of the week. There are of course occasions when mail is not delivered every day and they are classed as either USO failures or delivery exception cases. Postcomm recently conducted a consultation to review Royal Mail’s Universal Service Obligation for Delivery Services. We welcomed the opportunity to comment on this consultation.

Following publication of the consultation, our key concerns within the consultation were:
- 15 minute rule
- Health and Safety assessments
- Appeals process

The 15 minute rule defines whether an address along a private access road or track in poor condition should receive daily postal deliveries. If it takes more than 15 minutes for the round trip from the public road to reach the address, Royal Mail does not have to deliver to the premises, but will seek to agree an alternative delivery arrangement such as a roadside box.

We believe that the 15 minute rule should be retained but if there is any flexibility in individual circumstances, it should be weighted in favour of the mail recipients. We consider that it would be more beneficial for Postcomm to consider exceptions made under the 15 minute rule in a broader context, for example, looking at the geographical area that the exception is based in, and comparing it to deliveries made in similar areas.

Under the current policy, Royal Mail is entitled to continue to categorise addresses as long term health and safety exceptions if the condition of the access to the premises would present health and safety risks to Royal Mail staff if they carried out deliveries. Royal Mail may only make a long term exception or temporary suspension on health & safety grounds. This entails trained Royal Mail staff undertaking a health & safety risk assessment before reaching a long term exception.

We consider that the health & safety process needs to be more streamlined, with all three organisations, Postcomm, Postwatch and Royal Mail playing an equal role in deciding an exception. It should also take account of local circumstances, geography, weather conditions, custom and practice in the ways of working in the area.

We believe that Royal Mail’s estimated cost of delivering 3 times a week to excepted cases is not adequate. We consider that it would be beneficial for Royal Mail to employ a third party to deliver to these excepted cases that are more familiar with the area. This will benefit Royal Mail by ensuring its USO is not affected by stopping deliveries to these areas. We believe that the minimum delivery requirement should be raised to 3 times a week.

We see no reason why Royal Mail needs to have two stages for an appeal, when the exception is originally decided by the Delivery Office Manager. We agree that Stages 1 and 2 should be combined, and we believe that extending the time frame for Stage 3 will allow us to conduct a more thorough analysis of the case, which will prove to be more beneficial for all parties involved. Furthermore, we strongly believe it necessary for Postcomm to have a time limit for Stage 4 appeal, as this is fairer to the consumer. We believe that a three stage appeals process is more efficient and effective, with strict time limits and an improved definition, for each party to whom the appellant contacts, of their duties.

To read our full response, please click here.

Colin remains at his post

Anyone really interested in the future of the post office network will have come across the indefatigable Colin Baker, General Secretary of the National Federation of Subpostmasters. Colin was due to retire in March 2007, but the NFSP Executive Council was concerned at losing his expertise, just at the time when the Government is about to make a major announcement on the future of the post office network.

Therefore it has been agreed that Colin will stay on as General Secretary until 31 March 2008 at the latest. Postwatch looks forward to working with Colin and his NFSP colleagues in the discussions ahead on the vital role of our local post offices.

Thursday, November 09, 2006

Unwanted Mail

There has been a considerable amount of recent publicity about 'junk mail'. Whilst many of us don't mind receiving special offers or money-off vouchers through the post, some of us do consider this type of mail a nuisance. Recipients should be able to exercise a choice as to whether they receive this mail or not.

There are two types of advertising mail - addressed and unaddressed. Advertising mail is delivered by a range of organisations – including Royal Mail and other licensed postal operators, but also by local businesses. Under the Postal Services Act 2000 all licensed operators are obliged to deliver all mail items unless the contents have been proven to be illegal or in breach of British Codes of Advertising and Sales Promotion. There are, however, a number of services available that attempt to stop advertising mail at its source.

Mailing Preference Service
The Mailing Preference Service (MPS) is a free service set up and funded by the direct mail industry to enable consumers to have their names and home addresses in the UK removed from lists used by companies which use direct mail marketing. MPS can remove customer details from up to 95% of Direct Mail lists. It will not stop mail that has been sent from overseas, unaddressed material or mail addressed to The Occupier. It can take up to 4 months for MPS to have full effect although customers should notice a reduction of the mail during this period.

Customers can register for MPS by writing to:

Mailing Preference Service
FREEPOST 29
LON 20771
LONDON
W1E 0ZT

Or by visiting the website at: http://www.mpsonline.org.uk/

Royal Mail’s Opt out Service for unaddressed mail

Customers can also reduce the amount of unaddressed mail they receive by registering for Royal Mail’s Opt Out Service. Royal Mail claim they deliver only about 25% of unaddressed mail.

If customers wish to opt out of receiving unaddressed mail they can either call 08457 950 950 or alternatively write to:

Door to Door Opt Outs
Royal Mail
Kingsmead House
Oxpens Road
Oxford
OX1 1RX

Opting out of 'Door to Door' will mean that you will not receive Government literature (although any vital communications will be delivered). Polling and electoral registration material is unaffected.

Wednesday, November 08, 2006

Beware of parcel scams

It has come to our attention that a chain e-mail has been circulating the Internet. It makes reference to a company called Parcel Delivery Services. It calls on the recipient to access a premium rate telephone number which is very costly to the caller and simply makes money for a scammer.

ICSTIS - the regulator for premium rate telephone services - appreciates that consumers want to find out more information about this sort of scam and have issued this statement.

A new (re)Direction?

The UK postal market was fully opened on the 1 January 2006 and there are now 19 licensed operators. Since the start of the year it has been increasingly important to ensure that the services offered to customers are effective in a multi-operator market place.

With this in mind Postcomm, the economic regulator, published a consultation document on the sharing of redirection data in August this year in order to safeguard this vital service. Many of us will have used Royal Mail's redirection service in the past and quite rightly expect that 100% of our mail is redirected to our new address. As there are now a number of operators within the market the need for them to be aware of any redirections will grow as competition moves forward. The hope is that the sharing of this data will mean that all mail, whichever operator it is handled by, will be successfully redirected.

The security of personal data has been a hot topic recently and Postwatch are keen to ensure that redirection data is only shared with those that really need it. You can see the Postwatch response to the consultation here

Tuesday, November 07, 2006

What IS Santa doing down that chimney?

The "Mirror" newspaper today looks at the new Christmas stamps and wonders what is happening on the first class stamp. Is Santa spending a penny on a 32p stamp? Take a look and you decide.

Saturday, November 04, 2006

Keeping tabs on pillar boxes

Royal Mail's Chief Executive has given new assurances to Postwatch on the restoration of collection tabs - the small metal plates on pillar boxes that tell customers whether the last collection of the day has been made from that box.

Royal Mail removed tabs in 2002, prompting Postwatch, Postcomm, and other organisations such as Age Concern, to campaign for their reinstatement. Royal Mail promised to put them back on most of the 116,000 post boxes in the UK (about 23,000 cannot display tabs), but three surveys by Postwatch have found slow progress. The last survey - conducted in September - revealed that one in every four post boxes failed to display the correct collection tab, despite Royal Mail’s commitment to fully reintroduce the tabs by June.

Following this latest survey, Postwatch Chairman Millie Banerjee wrote to Royal Mail Chief Executive Adam Crozier calling on the business to honour its commitment and Mr Cozier has now responded as follows:

"It is helpful that your team have provided us with the details about the individual boxes that were surveyed where the tab was missing or incorrect. We have now made arrangements with your team to investigate every single case.

Operational colleagues will also be considering any generic causes that can be remedied and they will be targeting improvements through communications, briefings and associated coaching to ensure the deployment situation improves.

Arrangements have already been established via our Customer Service team to rectify any future cases where customers identify problems with tabs. This will link with the comment in your letter where you state that you will urge customers to report absent or wrong tabs to our helpline.

Additionally, if any Postwatch staff or Council member identify any further individual cases, please ask them to feed them through to our Customer Service team."

Customers who notice a tab is missing or incorrect should complain to Royal Mail by calling its 08457 740 740 helpline.

Friday, November 03, 2006

Keeping us posted

The Mail Show is the major event reviewing the state of the UK mail industry and the seventh such conference was held this week in central London. Generally speaking the picture was "cautiously encouraging" for Royal Mail's competitors.

Postcomm Chief Executive Sarah Chambers reported that the regulator had just licensed the 18th competitor to Royal Mail and that in name terms these 18 rivals now run from A (ANC Express) to Z (Zipmail).

She explained that Royal Mail made 1.2 billion access deliveries in 2005/06, compared to 87 million the previous year. In the five months to August 2006, access volumes have continued to grow, and latest figures show that access accounted for 10.5 % of Royal Mail’s total letters volume.

Competitor TNT was represented on the platform by CEO Nick Wells who suggested that his company would want to move beyond simply using Royal Mail's network through downstream access: "We will clearly want to have our own orange postmen on the streets". James Greenbury, CEO of DX/SMS, made it clear that his company wants to build an end to end network.

However, there was some concern about mail volumes in the UK. Volumes were down 1.1% last year. Direct mail, financial services, and transactional mail are all falling, but publishing and fulfillment are rising. Many contributors saw more scope for growth in direct mail, esecially if it was more targeted and innovative.

However, some international contributors reported declining mail volumes in their countries. Ireland - which already has half the mail volumes of the UK in per capita terms - is seeing serious decline in mail (10% in the last four years, perhaps because of the absence of post codes). France and Germany too are seeing a decline.

Thursday, November 02, 2006

Making plans for Nigel

Postwatch is delighted that Nigel Stapleton has been reappointed for a further 4 years as the Chair of Postcomm. This important decision will allow Nigel to complete the Strategy Review that has been started and to implement the customer-focussed policies that will result from it.

Nigel will also be able to oversee the further development of increased competition. The limited competition that already exists has led to significant improvements in the quality of service for all customers.