Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Millionth customer for PO Financial Services

Post Office Financial Services – a joint venture with Bank of Ireland - has welcomed its millionth customer, just over three years since its launch.

The exceptional growth of Post Office Financial Services is such that:
  • The Post Office sells one in 50 of all car insurance policies in the UK
  • One in every 25 credit cards issued last year was from the Post Office
  • £2 billion has been invested in the Post Office’s savings products
  • One in every 200 homes in the UK is insured with the Post Office

Labels:

Thursday, May 24, 2007

Defining and defending the USO

This week, we've been blogging on a couple of international conferences concerned with the postal business. Postwatch made a particular contribution to the session on "The role of the Universal Service Obligation".

Joost Vantomme, the Director for Regulatory Affairs at Belgian Post, spoke to the title "The preservation of the USO requires a legally certain and secure financing in case of the removal of the reserved area", while Almast Diedrich, Head of Public Affairs at TNT Post (the Dutch postal service) had as the title of his address "The USO is a commercial advantage for posts and needs no subsidy".

The speaker for Postwatch was our Council member for the Greater London Region, Roger Darlington. He was given the title: "How important is a USO in an age of multiple communication channels?" He suggested that implicit in the title given him was the suggestion that the widespread use of e-mail and the Internet meant that the current USO was no longer necessary. He pointed out, however, that in the UK:
  • Some 39% of homes are not connected to the Internet.
  • Older consumers are proportionately more likely not to be connected - only 30% of those aged over 65.
  • Poorer consumers are proportionately more likely not to be connected - only 36% of low income households.
  • Consumers with special needs have problems with use of the Net.
So he acknowledged that the scope and funding of the USO have to be kept under review and could not be regarded as fixed, but argued that currently there was no case for viewing the USO as less important.

Labels:

Wednesday, May 23, 2007

Regulatory ruminations

Today was the second and final day of the 27th annual World Mail & Express Europe conference here in London. This morning, the conference was addressed by John Ivers, the Director Licensing Framework & Market Intelligence at the regulator Postcomm.

He spent quite a lot of time analysing the volume and composition of UK mail. He explained that, since 2001, the historic relationship between GDP growth and growth in overall mail volumes has broken down with actual declines in total volumes in the last two yrears. The UK has the second highest number of items posted per household in Europe and he speculated that the UK mail industry may now have reached maturity.

On the other hand, he insisted that decline in mail volume is "not a natural law" and that some parts of the market - such as business to consumer mail and fulfillment - are still growing. Drawing on research by Pitney Bowes, he argued that "Internet users receive more physical mail than those who do not use the Internet" (although those not on the Net tend to be older and poorer consumers).

Touching on the universal service obligation, he said that the USO should be "one evolving in scope and service to meet the changing needs of customers in an increasingly dynamic market" - which seems somewhat coded.

Finally looking more to the future, he referred to Postcomm's Strategy Review which was launched with a consultation document as long ago as August 2006. He said that an "Emerging Views" document would be published "around July". In the Q&A session, Postwatch Council member Roger Darlington expressed disappointment that submissions on the orginal discussion document on the review were required by 9 November 2006 and no new document would be available for eight months after those views were submitted.

Postcomm has a London Forum on 12 June and Postwatch would have expected the "Emerging Views" document to have been published before that event, so that public discussion could have begun at the Forum. After all in the Foreword to the original discussion document, Postcomm Chairman Nigel Stapleton stated: "Our plan is to provide feedback to this consultation as early as possible in 2007".

Labels:

Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Postal pieces

Today and tomorrow Triangle Management Services are holding the 27th annual World Mail & Express Europe conference here in London. The "Welcome to London" was given by Royal Mail's Chief Executive Adam Crozier. He referred to the creation of a wholesale business unit in Royal Mail as unique in the worldwide postal industry and emphasized that "The role of posts in our society is changing".

One of today's speakers was Alex Bachelor, Marketing Director at Royal Mail. His address was entitled "Corporate turnaround: the new Royal Mail".

In an ebullient performance, he explained how the current management team has turned Royal Mail from losses to profit and restored quality of service. But he admitted that the changes had been slow coming: the single daily delivery (SDD) was introduced 20 years after it was first talked about and Pricing in Proportion (PiP) was introduced 11 years after it was first mooted. Also he acknowledged the human cost - a reduction of 33,000 in full-time employees and of 20,000 in temporary staff - while trumpeting the introduction of a five-day week for staff and a 25% increase in pay since March 2002.

Predictably he challenged the current regulatory framework as it bites on Royal Mail: "Our regulator is proactively promoting competition but, at the same time, constraining our commercial freeedom". He emphasized that Royal Mail has 'lost' 2.5 billion items of mail a year to downstream access and pointed out that this was happening at a time when market volumes are decreasing for the first time in a decade.

The delegates to the conference were supplied with electronic voting handsets and the chairman of this particular session asked us to vote on whether we thought that, following this "corporate turnaround", Royal Mail is now in the top flight of postal operators worldwide. Some 38% said 'Yes', while 35% answered 'No', and the rest were unsure.

Labels:

Monday, May 21, 2007

Network nuggets

Today Triangle Management Services held a conference in London entiled "World Postal Retail Networks". Amazingly it seems that this event was the first world conference dedicated specially to postal retail networks and there were representatives from 25 countries, including New Zealand, South Africa, Israel, Egypt and Chile.

The Chief Executive of Postwatch Howard Webber chaired the afternoon session and Postwatch Council member Roger Darlington and Network Team member Andy Burrows were also there.

For us, there was special interest in the presentation by Alan Cook, Managing Director of Post Office Ltd. Much of the material was familiar but there were a few new nuggets such as:
  • Last financial year, POL had £168M less business from the Government than the previous year.
  • POL ran 18 different scenarios for the Government before it decided on the plan for 2,500 post office closures.
  • The Horizon computer system takes £100M a year to run which is excessive.
  • The current range of POL products - some 170 - is "ridiculous" and needs to be reduced.
  • By 2011, some 20% of POL transactions are expected to be conducted by telephone or the Internet.
Alan Cook outlined a strategy focusing on four main product lines: mails and retail, financial services, government services, and telecommunications. The HomePhone proposition is to be relaunched and a new broadband service is to be launched with the expection that, by 2011, 14% of revenues will come from telecoms.

From his staff, he is looking for "an open, customer-focused, commercial, performance-driven culture".

Labels:

Friday, May 18, 2007

Prices under control?

Postwatch has submitted its response to Postomm's consultation on revisiting certain aspects of the price control.

For Postwatch (and for Postcomm also) it is imperative that the outcome of these applications should be a price control that is balanced fairly between customers, efficiency, competition and protecting the universal service.

To achieve this, Postcomm needs:
- sufficient and reliable data on Royal Mail’s internal workings;

- sufficient and reliable data on trends in (and beyond) the mail market; and

- to apply a rigorous, independent and transparent analysis of such data to test the applications by Royal Mail and UK Mail/TNT.


Postwatch believes that Postcomm is essentially being asked to re-set:

- the price control,

- Royal Mail’s charges for access to its upstream business (through access arrangements), and

- Royal Mail’s charges for use of its downstream delivery business, and the apportionment of those charges between wholesale and retail customers (zonal pricing).

These issues affect every aspect of Royal Mail’s business and go the heart of the mail service as a regulated industry. We urge Postcomm to undertake a transparent and objective analysis not only of the data supplied in these applications but also of the data omitted from it - and to publish the results of this analysis before they make their decision.

At that point, and only at that point, we believe Postcomm will be in a position to determine how far granting or refusing these applications will reconcile the aims of protecting the universal service, promoting efficiency within Royal Mail and ensuring the maximum consumer benefit from competition. Until then, it is difficult to look favourably at an application which seeks major changes to a price control agreed little more than a year ago.

The full text of the response can be viewed here.

Labels: , , ,

The C-factor

Royal Mail has formally applied for a suspension of the bulk mail compensation scheme and the so-called ‘C-factor’, should industrial action take place.

The C-factor is a pricing tool built into Royal Mail’s licence which aims to compensate customers should quality of service targets not be hit. It provides Royal Mail an incentive to hit quality of service targets by reducing Royal Mail’s ability to increase prices if targets are not met.

The application made by Royal Mail to Postcomm can be found here.

Postwatch will be writing to Postcomm in the following days to express its opinion on the application.

Labels: , ,

2,500 Post Offices to close

Postwatch recognise that yesterday’s announcement by the government that 2,500 post offices will be closed over the next 18 months will be unpopular and worry some customers. However, the reality of the situation is that without severe pruning the whole network was in jeopardy.

It is without doubt in the best interests of customers that post office closures are planned rather than unplanned. If the government had not taken its decision we fear there would have been a large number of unplanned closures that could have resulted in gaps in the network.

Postwatch is not, of course, happy with all aspects of the government’s announcement. However, we have to recognise that decisions have been taken and rather than try to get them changed our efforts have to be fully directed towards getting the best possible outcome for customers. In many ways it will be up to Postwatch to ensure local consultations on area plans are meaningful and that proper attention is paid to points raised.

Postwatch is particularly pleased that the government have agreed that local factors like public transport links, the impact on the local economy and demographics will be assessed when applying the basic distance based access criteria.

No-one at this stage knows which post offices will close.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

EDM on postal services

An Early Day Motion (EDM) is a Parliamentary device to draw attention to a matter in the House of Commons. Labour MP for Luton North Kelvin Hopkins has just sponsored this EDM on postal services:

"That this House welcomes the commitment from the Labour Party in its General Election Manifesto 2005 that it will review the impact on the Royal Mail of market liberalisation, which is being progressively introduced under the Postal Services Act 2000 and which allows alternative carriers to the Royal Mail to offer postal services; notes that the manner in which competition has been introduced has resulted in Royal Mail losing 40 per cent. of its high revenue access products in three years and that this rate of losses will raise a question over the financing of the Universal Service Obligation by Royal Mail; further notes that there are options which the review can examine to support the Universal Delivery Service Obligation, such as a support fund or a supplement to the access price charged for competitors who currently receive the benefit of Royal Mail's Universal Service without paying for it; and calls upon the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry to ensure that the promised review is begun without delay."

Labels: ,

Opening of new post offices

Tomorrow we can expect to hear a Government statement confirming the proposed closure of some 2,500 post offices nation-wide. But, while sadly the total number of post offices has been in decline for some 20 years, there have still been new offices opened.

In a recent Parliamentary Answer, DTI Minister Jim Fitzpatrick gave these figures for new offices:

2004 190

2005 202

2006 239

Labels:

Friday, May 11, 2007

Postal Strike

Everything possible must be done to avoid a postal strike. A strike would be bad news for customers, bad news for the economy and bad news for Royal Mail and its workforce. If major mailers are forced to find other ways to communicate with customers or perspective customers they will and they may not return afterwards.

Perhaps the biggest threat to Royal Mail’s future profitability will be a decline in the total mail market – which a strike will exacerbate. After years of year on year growth mail volumes have fallen in the last year or so. No-one can at this stage say whether this is a blip or the start of a very worrying trend. What is clear is that strike or even the threat of one will drive business away

Labels: , ,

How many of out 10?

In a full-page profile in the "Guardian" newspaper today, Royal Mail's Chief Executive Adam Crozier comments:
"It is still work in progress. When you have got an organisation that didn't change for a long time then goes through four years of change, there is a tendency to then go, phew, that's great, we've changed, now we can go back to normal - but if we started off at minus five out of 10, I think we are now at four out of 10."

Labels: ,

Thursday, May 03, 2007

Quality scheme closes

The organisation which provides independent quality accreditation for the direct mail industry, QMP, is to close following changes made to Royal Mail's internal processes.

The independent accreditation scheme operated by QMP has policed quality standards in mail production at mailing houses since 2001. Mailing Houses had to sign up to QMP's standards - and accept regular audits - before they were eligible for Royal Mail's commission scheme.

Royal Mail now proposes to replace the quality-assured gateway with a scheme based solely on rewarding Mailing Houses for volume, and meeting Royal Mail's presentation criteria.

Last year alone, QMP conducted some 150 audits of Mailing House sites, has issued almost 100 improvement notices and suspended 5 sites, all of which made a positive impact on industry standards and ultimately how and what the consumer receives through the post.

Industry standards schemes with multiple level participation are generally good for consumers and for industry reputations, so it seems regretable that this scheme is closing.

Tuesday, May 01, 2007

A query from a postie

The postman of a Postwatch Council member has asked the following question: "When does Royal Mail's contract to deliver mail six days a week expire?" It's not clear why the question was asked but there is a clear answer.

Royal Mail - like other operators - has contracts with various large users, although this is probably not what the postman has in mind. All mail operators, including Royal Mail, require a licence from Postcomm. Royal Mail's licence requires it to provide universal postal services which include delivery of mail to all homes six days a week. Royal Mail was granted its current 15 year licence on 23 March 2001, so the current licence will expire on 23 March 2016, but it will of course be reissued before then.

However, Postcomm is responsible for defining the scope of the universal service - and that may change over time, as postal users’ requirements change – as well as assessing its cost and benefit to Royal Mail. No change to the universal service would be made, however, without a full public consultation process by Postcomm. There are no current proposals to change the universal service obligation, although the nature and funding of the USO in the longer term is part of Postcomm's current Strategy Review.

We hope that this clarifies things.

Regulator fails to deliver protection for UK addresses

In August 2006, Postcomm published a consultation document on the Review of Policy on Exceptions to the Universal Service Obligation on delivery services. The Decision and Direction document on this consultation has now been published.

Under the Postal Services Act 2000, Postcomm has a duty to obligate Royal Mail to deliver six days a week to every home or premises in the UK, subject only to exceptions determined by Postcomm.

The purpose of this consultation was to allow Postcomm the opportunity to test whether the low level of appeal cases (15 in total, only 8 have been dealt by Postcomm) over the past two years was a true reflection of customer satisfaction. It also aimed to assess whether the key aims of Postcomm’s policy regarding deliveries were being met.

We are disappointed with the outcome of Postcomm’s decision document following its policy review of exceptions to Royal Mail’s Universal Delivery Service, as we believe that Postcomm has not considered how the measurement process for exempting an address is still highly detrimental to customers.

Postwatch is concerned with the timescale Postcomm has given itself with the appeals process. Postcomm has given an indicative timescale of six months, from the receipt of a Stage 4 appeal from a customer or Royal Mail, to issue a decision. It goes on to state that Postcomm would be open to judicial review if it does not issue a decision within a reasonable time.

This is completely detrimental for customers, as it is highly unlikely that individual customers will have the chance or resource to take Postcomm, the regulator to a judicial review.

With regards to addresses that get a less than daily delivery of mail, Postcomm stated that due to changes in the technical, economic and social environment since 2003 they did not need to consider a higher minimum delivery frequency of more than once a week. Postwatch believe that when deliveries are at a level of once a week, it deprives the recipient of access to a range of services, such as hospital appointments and also, in certain circumstances adds additional costs to other organisations. The increase of technology does not necessarily mean that people depend less on the postal service.

To read the Decision Document in full, please click here.