Friday, December 29, 2006

The judgement of Solomon

"Royal Mail's letters business is a conundrum. A state-owned organisation operating in a free market. Charged with making profits but obliged to offer a universal service delivering to 27m addresses six days a week. The competition wants to dig deep into its market share and for a year has had the freedom to do so. Top management wants to open up the share capital to the workforce - a proposal that leaves the government facing a judgment that would stretch Solomon."
This is the opening paragraph of a one-page feature on Royal Mail in today's "Guardian" newspaper

Thursday, December 21, 2006

A very special delivery

Royal Mail have applied to make changes to the Special Delivery Next Day service and plan to introduce a service called Special Delivery High Value. This would be used when someone wished to send cash, or items of particularly high value, through the post.

Postcomm decided that it was important to conduct a consultation on this issue and you can view our response here.

Tuesday, December 19, 2006

A (one-time) house divided

Until 1981, BT and Royal Mail were one organisation (The Post Office). However, since the split, there have been major business rivalries between the two companies.

BT provides the telecommunications network and an Internet service which offer increasing opportunities for e-substitution with a growing number of communications going by e-mail instead of the post. For its part, Royal Mail once ran a rival telephone network (National Network) and today operates a rival telephone service (HomePhone).

That's fine - as long as the competition is fair. But telecoms regulator Ofcom has just launched an enquiry into Post Office Limited's telephone service which has been accused of 'slamming' - that is, switching customers from BT without their permission.

Postwatch’s remit only covers postal services; however if subpostmasters and Post Office Ltd are to benefit from this wider offering of products, confidence in the Post Office Ltd brand must remain.

Lib Dem spokesperson for posts

Liberal Democrat Leader Menzies Campbell has announced new roles and appointments in his Shadow Cabinet as a key stage in the party’s preparations for he sees as possible 2007 General Election. Edward Davey becomes the Leader’s new Chief of Staff, which will be alongside his present role as Chair of Campaigns and Communications, so the DTI portfolio - which includes postal matters - is now taken on by Susan Kramer, the MP for Richmond.

Monday, December 18, 2006

Postal prices to rise - again

Royal Mail has made an announcement today that postal prices are to rise from 2 April 2007.

The first class stamp will go up from 32p to 34p - an increase of 6.25%. The second class stamp will rise from 23p to 24p - an increase of 4.35%. The differential between the first and second class stamp will go up from 9p (39%) to 10p (42%).

Royal Mail agreed a 4 year price control with Postcomm that came into affect in April 2006 and runs to March 2010. The agreement gave Royal Mail the flexibility to raise the price of a 1st class stamp by 2009/10 to 36p (from 30p).

This agreement also gives Royal Mail the flexibility to adjust its prices, but it has to give customers 3 months notice. Royal Mail has today announced the changes to its prices that will come into effect in April 2007 – so giving the 3 month notice required.

Millie Banerjee, Chair of Postwatch, commenting on the increases said:

“The price of posting has been complicated by the introduction of Pricing in Proportion in August 2006. Next April’s increases are the first to involve stamps for ‘large letters’. This adds another level of complexity that customers have to understand and it is important that they do. As an example, the cost of sending an A4 sheet of paper first class through the post will have risen from 30 pence in March 2006 to 48 pence in April 2007 – a rise of 60 per cent.

“Clearly price rises that are above the rate of inflation are unwelcome to customers. It is disappointing but not surprising that Royal Mail is putting up prices as quickly as it is allowed to so as to try to maximize its revenues over the price control period. It is, of course, unlikely that the majority of stamp using customers will be offered competitive alternatives to Royal Mail’s services for sometime – they are therefore to some extent captive customers whose only option is whether to post or not – not who to post with."

Thursday, December 14, 2006

It is not a numbers game

The government today published its proposals for the future of the post office network. This involves the closing of 2,500 post offices and that is not good news, even though it is generally accepted that some pruning was necessary for the good of the network as a whole.

The whole issue has quickly been whittled down to the number of post offices that will be closed. This misses the point.

The focus of the debate should not be on the number of post office buildings that can be maintained but about ensuring everyone has at least reasonable access to post office services. If a number of expensive to run post office buildings can be replaced with a cost-effective mobile service doesn't that make sense?

Postwatch will study the consultation document carefully but one of our initial concerns is that the DTI have not explained in its document how unplanned closures will be prevented. There are known to be more subpostmasters who want to accept compensation than there are those will get it.

Commonsense suggests these people have accepted they are leaving the industry and are might well decide to go. If the post office they are leaving is a loss-maker it may be difficult to organise for anyone to take it over. This could leave a gap in the network.

Postwatch Press Release
Postwatch background briefing

Wednesday, December 13, 2006

Tomorrow's the day...

And so tomorrow's the day that we finally learn the Government's strategy for the future of the network.

For over a year, Postwatch has been calling for Government to come forward with proposals for putting in place a sustainable means of meeting customers' post office needs.

Visit the Postwatch website for background to the consultation, and read the topline findings of research commissioned by Postwatch on customer needs in rural and deprived urban areas.

Tuesday, December 12, 2006

Remembering public sector customers

The Postal Services Act 2000 places an obligation on Postwatch to represent all customers - a responsibilty we take very seriously.

We endeavour to represent social customers by receiving and (as far as possible) resolving their complaints through our Contact Centre in Belfast, by engaging with local consumers through our Regional Teams and Regional Committees, and by conducting independent research.

We engage with private sector businesses through bodies like the Trade Association Forum and the Personal and Small Business Mail Users Group.

But we are aware that we must not forget the public sector. National and local government plus the education and health sectors are enormous users of mail and, so far, few bodies in this sector have taken advantage of the competitive choice which is now available in the postal marketplace.

A few days ago, on behalf of Postwatch I addressed a meeting in Guildford of the Mailing Services Commodity Group of the Government Department DEFRA. One of the things we discussed is how Postwatch can work more closely with public sector customers of the mails service through bodies like the Postal Users' Forum of the Office of Government Commerce.

Monday, December 11, 2006

Waiting for Government (2) ...

In its own news announcement on the prospect of a Government statement on the post office network, the National Federation of SubPostmasters (NFSP) asserts: "This is a recovery package not a closure programme".

Media reports - such as this one - quote NSFP Secretary General Colin Baker as calling for "a grown up discussion" on the future of the network.

Sunday, December 10, 2006

Waiting for Government (1) ...

There's been a lot of media speculation this weekend about the Government statement expected on Thursday concerning the future of the Post Office network. Postwatch has refused to join the speculation, but has issued the following short statement to the Press Association:

“We’ve been urging the Government for many months to come forward with proposals on future funding and structural arrangements for the post office network. We therefore look forward to an announcement and to responding on behalf of customers.

Postwatch wants to see action that will give the rural network long-term certainty. Without reform, unplanned rural closures will continue. Despite the funding, there have been 1,000 closures in rural areas of the UK over the past five years.

It is essential that investment in the rural network continues beyond April 2008, the current funding cut-off date, and that a strategic, customer-led approach to meeting rural communities’ postal needs is put in place. Postwatch believes the focus of the forthcoming debate should be about access to post office services, not solely about post office numbers.”

Friday, December 08, 2006

An urban problem too...

New research this week suggests that customers in urban areas can suffer just as much from the closure of local post offices as those in isolated rural locations.

The research, from the New Economics Foundation (NEF), shows that for every post office closure in rural areas since 2004, eight urban post offices have also shut. The closure of a post office makes a significant dent to local economies, and hits the social fabric of often disadvantaged communities.

Read the report here.

It’s worth remembering that in many deprived urban locations, vulnerable customers are reliant on the post office network for postal services, bill payments and access to cash, as are local businesses and economic enterprises.

It’s for this reason that Postwatch worked hard to get the urban deprived network included in the consultation on the network’s future, to be announced in the next few days. Urban Reinvention aimed to create a sustainable urban network – and yet in spite of this, a number of challenges to the future viability of the UK’s social post offices remain.

Postwatch anticipates the consultation as a valuable opportunity to stress to government the need for a long-term vision for the UK’s social post office network.

High Standards at Royal Mail

Following the release of Royal Mail’s latest quality of service report, (see the earlier ‘blog “A first class performance”), Postwatch undertook a review of the full results, and found improvements in many areas of Royal Mail’s performance.

Royal Mail’s quality of service is measured against 12 targets, and for the period April to September Royal Mail met or exceeded 11 of these targets. In previous years Royal Mail has failed to achieve many of the set targets, so it is encouraging that for the first time since targets were introduced as part of Royal Mail’s licence in 2001, Royal Mail has a realistic chance of exceeding all of its quality of service targets for the full year.

The headline figures from the report show that 94.4% of 1st class mail arrived next day (target 93%) and 99.1% of 2nd class mail arrived within 3 days (target 98.5%). The best performing postcode area in terms of 1st class mail was Swindon, which managed to ensure 97.4% of 1st class mail arrived the next day after posting.

Standard Parcels continued to perform above target, with performance recorded at 94.7% (target 90%). This performance was the best performance for this product since standards of service measurements were introduced, up 0.5% from Quarter 1 2006-07.

Performance for Special Delivery from April to September continued to exceed its target of 99%, recording a performance of 99.1% for the period. This is encouraging, since Special Delivery is a premium Royal Mail product, and had frequently failed to achieve its target in the past.

In terms of Royal Mail achieving its Universal Service Obligation (USO), the quality of service results showed 99.95% of collection points are being served each day (target 99.9%), and 99.98% of delivery routes are completed each day (target 99.9%).

Royal Mail is also delivering more items correctly than previously, with 99.65% of mail being delivered to the correct address or addressee (target 99.5%).

The overall picture painted by the quality of service results is encouraging. Postwatch are pleased to commend Royal Mail on their performance, and hope the continued improvement in terms of quality of service continues.

Small businesses and the posts

This week, the Federation of Small Businesses published a reprt entitled "Small Businesses And The UK Postal Market".

The report points out that there are 4.3 million small businesses in the UK which contribute 52% of K GDP and employ 58% of the private sector workforce. It argues that: "The postal system remains crucial to maintain the smooth running of a small business from both a communication and financial aspect".

The report outlines the results of survey with 3,356 reponses which found that 88% of respondents send post every day and 69% send invoices through the posts.

The FSB concludes: "There is uncertainty as to whether the new liberalised postal market will benefit small businesses, particuarly those in traditional non-profit making areas".

FSB official Francesca Woodhouse put the findings of the report to DTI Minister for Posts Jim Fitzpatrick at a meeting this week of the Counters Advisory Group convened by Postwatch at its London officies.

Wednesday, December 06, 2006

A fair deal?

Every customer of Royal Mail has the right to expect that when they send an item through the post that it will arrive on time and in one piece. On occasion, however, this is not the case and the item is either lost, late or damaged. When this happens most people will expect some form of compensation but finding out what they can claim can be a complicated and confusing process.

Postcomm, the postal services regulator, has published the first of three consultation documents on Royal Mail's compensation scheme and invites responses by 13 February 2006. You can see the document here. Postwatch will be submitting a response which will be published on our website.